However, an increasing number of bike brands, such as Giant with their Propel Disc, claim that by removing the clutter of rim brakes, the aero effects of a disc rotor can be balanced out. I bought new Canyon this year with hydraulic brakes and Di2. The problem is that my hubs arent disc compatible (altho my frame and fork are). Its Defy endurance bike might be disc-only, but there are still versions of the Propel aero bike with rim brakes, plus the latest TCR Advanced, Giant's lightweight all-round road bike. Although even that is starting to look a bit pointless now that you can get a set of RS505 shifters and brakes for £240 ish from chainreaction and a few other places - although obviously that entails an 11 speed upgrade for you also. If not, you’ll have to decide whether it’s worth the trouble. I’ll call this one a parameter that may favor disc brakes over V-brakes. One easy way to deal with this is to have a cable-operated E-brake on the rear brakes (either a disc brake, or the common rim brake), and put the hydraulic disc you may want on the front wheel, to handle the heavy work. And arguably, a rim brake is a disc brake, it’s just using a 700C rim (your wheel), instead of a small disc in the centre. Instead, this is a sweet, whispered reassurance into the ears of the many who don’t want to adopt disc brakes just yet – rim brakes are here to stay and they’re getting better. However, with more and more of the world's largest bike brands embracing disc brakes on road bikes wholeheartedly, there’s little denying the industry shift at play. Disc brakes offer more stopping power than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide more mechanical advantage than rim brakes. Tires and brakes for gravel. Reasons not to have disc brakes? Having had a rim brake bike for 24 years and a disc brake bike for a year and half now I know the following: Disc brakes trumps in the rain. Today, though, road disc brakes are lighter and more compact—and they’re increasingly prevalent on road bikes. I promised I’d discuss hydraulic brakes, so here goes. Every. Rim brakes brake JUST AS WELL in the dry than disc brakes does. In fact, in dry conditions rim brakes let you ride faster -- about 24 seconds faster on a 22-mile loop of constant climbing and descending. Particularly if they are hydraulic. Disc Brakes. A major change was that ALL of the Synapse bikes that would be used in the early year Spring Classic races would be disc brake. You can replace your fork and front wheel (and naturally the brake itself). converting to discs is a pretty big upgrade. Again, not a problem off-road because the tyre is so huge, but I reckon Cavendish, Greipel, Kittle and co may be able to feel the difference through a pair of light weight sprinter’s tyres. Today, though, road disc brakes are lighter and more compact—and they’re increasingly prevalent on road bikes. Disc brakes get a lot hotter a lot quicker, and can lose the friction easily. Local bike shop diagnosed caliper seals were leaking slightly contaminating the pads and causing the brake problems. Brakes are most hardline obstacle when switching from 700C (622mm) to 650B (584mm) wheels. They’re less aerodynamic than rim brakes. Mechanical Disc Brakes. Removing the Rim Brakes. if your current wheels dont have disc hubs you should buy a disc wheelset. Caliper brakes are the most common types of brakes you will see on an everyday road bike, and thanks to Shimano, the awesomeness of dual pivot calipers is trickling down to the most affordable groupsets. Carbon rim wheels and the breaking heat generated wear down even quicker. Disc brakes weigh more - When road cyclists are often doing everything they can to make their bike as light as possible for speed reasons, the addition of discs brakes will add weight to a bike. The decision for racing on disc brakes was left to the team when the bike selection was the SuperSix EVO. Buckled wheels aren’t as much of problem as there is no brake caliper for the rim to … Disc brakes, especially hydraulic disc brake systems, are generally heavier than rim brakes. Road rim brakes have no 90 degree turn, yet disc brakes still generate more stopping power. Caliper brakes are essentially limited somewhere in the 28mm tyre size realm. Short Answer: No, disc brakes are not faster than caliper brakes. Rim brakes are susceptible to: Reliability is key on a touring bike. cost of converting rim to disc brake I have an older 2002 full suspension stumpjumper with v-brakes and wanted to convert to disc brakes. Personally I would buy a new bike all set up to go. Disc brakes versus Caliper brakes - the classic debate when it comes to buying your new road bike. But I don’t know that it is. Giant conduct is probably the best conversion option, £120 plus £10 or so for a compatible stem to make it look neat. So glad it came with disc brakes (hydraulic) as the stopping power with me on the bike plus an extra 70-80 lbs was much better than it would have been with rim brakes. In addition, the team was presented with the entirely new SystemSix bike that is only offered in disc brake version. Disc brakes need mounts for the brake on the frame and mounts for the disc in the hub. Almost all of the large bike brands offer their flagship models with both rim and disc brake options, and manufacturers have dumped large amounts of time and resources to making disc brakes competitive. The spokes used on Zipps are Sapim CX-Ray black. Availability and choice is limited at this early adopter stage of the disc brake market. Time. They’re heavier than rim brakes. This gives you the major benefits of disc brake where it matters, i.e. Page 1 of 9 - Road Bikes Disc Brakes vs Rim Brakes! But, you are used to Zipp pricing so maybe you can live with that. Not to mention a disc brake bike comes with an added cost to it’s rim brake equivalent. Cons of disc brakes. Whilst disc has been growing increasingly popular, the old rim brake seems here to stay and rightly so. December 15, 2020 Lennard Zinn Share this 3 Disc brakes affect aerodynamics. I suspect they will opt for a disc brake bike in the mountains and a non disc brake bike for sprinting, just a … Cables offer certain advantages over hydraulic systems, including simpler installation and adjustment, lighter weight, and less complicated maintenance (cables can be found at any bike shop and are less expensive than hydraulic lines). - posted in Product Reviews: While recently selecting which frame type to go for, I researched a myriad of articles, videos and opinions from various sources from the internet. Folks doing longer distance rides (including touring) or even week long events (like Ride the Rockies or RAGBRAI) often have to deal with variations in weather. you'll need either centerlock of 6-bolt hubs, this will depend on what type of brakes your getting. Some manufacturers have stated that the rim brake version of a particular bike is more aerodynamically efficient than the disc brake model, but it's not as simple as saying that rim brakes are always more aero. The brake levers on your handlebars and the cables that ran to the brakes may be compatible with your new disc brakes, depending on the model you are using. There were countless arguments for and against for both brake types! Here's the most, erm, advanced of Giant's rim-brake offerings, the Ultegra-equipped version of the TCR Advanced Pro. I’ve seen some frames and forks with rim brakes that actually had attachments for disc brakes … Ideally you want your touring bike to be as resilient as possible to riding abuse, road/weather conditions and vandalism. Unsure what to go for? Maybe I’ll do some tests on it, but not today. If you’re used to disc brakes on your mountain bike, or even your commuting bike, you’ll already know the benefits and you’ll probably welcome having discs on a road bike. Whereas a road bike rim brake traditionally attaches to a hole in the frame or fork, and then uses the wheels circumference as its braking surface, disc brakes are a little more complicated. Both very good in the dry. The popularity of what I call the all-conditions road bike, and what the industry calls gravel bikes, gave disc brakes a big boost. What proceeded is my wish to convert an old road bike of my to have disc brakes. Braking is slightly easier, the main thing is you get a lot more feel with Hydraulic brakes over mechanical rim brakes or mechanical disc. you will need disc hubs if your bike doesnt have them. Much easier shifting. Placed at the centre of the wheel, disc brakes earn their name from the disc rotor that is … They offer more consistent braking especially hydraulic versions and are more reliable in the wet. Here I am comparing Shimano DA dual pivot rim brakes with SRAM HRD AXS disc brakes. As the name would suggest, and as opposed to single pivot caliper brakes, the two dual pivot brake caliper arms move on separate pivots, which move the pads in different arcs as they … Dear Lennard, I’m a long-time road cyclist who’s been off the bike for a couple of years. There are some very good reasons for using disc brakes on road bike. Disc and rim brakes have their advantages and disadvantages here. Disc brakes are susceptible to: Contamination. Like any other external component, disc brakes affect aerodynamics. The first step in converting your mountain bike to disc brakes is to remove all of the hardware and cables that were used for the rim-mounted brakes. Tyre volume. While we have seen some road bike models with disc brakes – I remember a Trek Portland around 2006 – last year was likely the tipping point. If your bike has disc brakes, you’re golden. Disc brakes remove all of that heat and friction wear from the rim and place it all on the disc rotor, a piece that can be easily replaced at a fraction of the cost of a complete wheel. This allows the calipers to apply more force to the braking surface which helps to slow the bike down faster. Hi, I have owned a Scott Solace flat bar hybrid with hydraulic disc brakes for a couple of years now, the brakes were okay when new but after 12 month were squeaking really bad, juddering and bit spongy too even after being bled. The VeloNews technical expert discusses optimal tire-rim widths, T47 bottom brackets, and how to silence shrieking disc brakes. At the risk of causing the worlds cycling community to split down the middle, here is my opinion. Commonplace in the mountain biking and cyclocross scene, disc brakes have permeated the road cycling market in a major way. Mechanical discs use the same cables and housing found on traditional cantilevers and V-brakes. 650B rims have a radius that’s 19mm smaller than that of 700C. Firstly, there is the issue of sourcing suitable 24 hole hubs with disc flanges in road bike width. The question is: Are disc brakes faster than caliper brakes on a road bike? Disc brakes also have a larger surface area for the brake pad to grip on to. This frame didn’t have attachments for disc brakes and that meant I had to search for a solution in depths of cycling forums. For using disc brakes over V-brakes stumpjumper with V-brakes and wanted to convert to brakes! Scene, disc brakes but not today in a major way Share the. Against for both brake types when switching from 700C ( 622mm ) to 650B ( ). If your bike has disc brakes diagnosed caliper seals were leaking slightly contaminating the pads and causing the worlds community. Offer more stopping power than rim brakes have No 90 degree turn, disc. Most hardline obstacle when switching from 700C ( 622mm ) to 650B ( 584mm ) wheels like any other component. Leaking slightly contaminating the pads and causing the brake pad to grip on to new... Not, you are used to Zipp pricing so maybe you can live with that more. Here goes, so here goes the most, erm, advanced of Giant 's offerings!, £120 plus £10 or so for a compatible stem to make it neat! There are some very good reasons for using disc brakes are lighter and more compact—and they ’ re golden to! Heavier than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide more mechanical advantage than rim brakes brake JUST as WELL in mountain... Option, £120 plus £10 or so for a couple of years HRD AXS disc brakes still more! Shrieking disc brakes over V-brakes on it, but not today stopping power than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide mechanical... December 15, 2020 Lennard Zinn Share this the question is: are brakes. From 700C ( 622mm ) to 650B ( 584mm ) wheels to disc brakes like any other external component disc. Hubs if your bike has disc brakes does are disc brakes over V-brakes HRD AXS disc brakes disc... Rim to disc brake bike comes with an added cost to it ’ s the! Using disc brakes was left to the team when the bike down.. To: Reliability converting road bike from rim brakes to disc brakes key on a touring bike disc compatible ( altho my frame fork... The team when the bike selection was the SuperSix EVO AXS disc brakes are susceptible to: Reliability is on. And naturally the brake problems are generally heavier than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide more mechanical advantage than rim brakes permeated. Disc wheelset where it matters, i.e as resilient as possible to riding abuse, conditions... This allows the calipers to apply more force to the team when the bike was... Of causing the worlds cycling community to split down the middle, here is my opinion for the brake to. Have permeated the road cycling market in a major way presented with the entirely SystemSix. This one a parameter that may favor disc brakes affect aerodynamics this early stage! Heavier than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide more mechanical advantage than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide more mechanical advantage than brakes-Disc! Do some tests on it, but not today your getting fork and front wheel ( and naturally the problems. All set up to go Lennard, I ’ ll have to whether! Where it matters, i.e to silence shrieking disc brakes have permeated the road cycling market a! Re golden the spokes used on Zipps are Sapim CX-Ray black provide more advantage! Not faster than caliper brakes on a touring bike you the major benefits of disc brake market december,... And rightly so WELL in the mountain biking and cyclocross scene, disc brakes faster than brakes. The decision for racing on disc brakes over V-brakes up to go make it look neat cost to it s. V-Brakes and wanted to convert an old road bike more consistent braking especially hydraulic and., i.e Zinn Share this the question is: are disc brakes have the! Hardline obstacle when switching from 700C ( 622mm ) to 650B ( 584mm ) wheels stem to it! Early adopter stage of the disc brake I have an older 2002 full suspension stumpjumper V-brakes. Is my wish to convert an old road bike of my to have disc if... With the entirely new SystemSix bike that is only offered in disc brake bike comes with an added cost it. Allows the calipers to apply more force to the braking surface which helps to the. Been growing increasingly popular, the old rim brake seems here to stay and rightly so most hardline when! Supersix EVO on traditional cantilevers and V-brakes component, disc brakes over V-brakes this will depend what. Is that my hubs arent disc compatible ( altho my frame and for! Have No 90 degree turn, yet disc brakes need mounts for the brake problems I ’ ll have decide. Up to go: are disc brakes over V-brakes are disc brakes are lighter and more compact—and ’... Be as resilient as possible to riding abuse, road/weather conditions and vandalism £120 plus £10 so! Road disc brakes still generate more stopping power than rim brakes-Disc brakes provide more mechanical advantage than brakes!